Prediction: CO₂/H₂O inversion in 3I/ATLAS

Empirical Predictions for 3I/ATLAS (October–December 2025)

Posted for independent verification and discussion

These predictions concern the expected compositional and photometric behaviour of the interstellar object 3I/ATLAS as it approaches and passes perihelion (~29 October 2025, r ≈ 1.36 AU). They are model-agnostic and intended purely as empirical expectations for comparison with forthcoming JWST and VLT datasets.

  1. CO₂/H₂O Ratio Inversion
    • At heliocentric distances > ~2.8 AU, the coma will remain CO₂-rich with weak H₂O signatures.
    • Near perihelion (~1.4 AU), the CO₂/H₂O ratio should decline, marking activation of deeper H₂O ices.
    • A measurable inversion of the ratio (relative to early observations) is expected between ~1.8 – 1.5 AU.

  2. Early Nickel Emission
    • Spectral lines of neutral or ionised Ni are predicted to appear before any Fe features or strong H₂O lines, likely between 3.0 – 2.5 AU.
    • Nickel activity should plateau or decline as the H₂O phase begins.

  3. Rotational Compositional Modulation
    • CO₂ and Ni emissions are expected to vary strongly with rotational phase, reflecting surface heterogeneity.
    • H₂O emission should be more uniform once deeper layers activate.

  4. Polarimetric and Grain-Size Evolution
    • Pre-perihelion dust will show higher polarisation (finer, porous grains).
    • As perihelion approaches, larger and less-porous grains from deeper layers will reduce polarisation by ~10–20 %.

  5. Post-Perihelion Hysteresis
    • Outgassing ratios will not retrace inbound values: CO₂ emission will drop faster than H₂O, producing a distinct hysteresis loop in compositional trends.

  6. Possible Isotopic Offset
    • Isotopic ratios in CO₂ may differ slightly from those in later-released H₂O (Δ(¹³C/¹²C) or Δ(¹⁸O/¹⁶O) ≈ few × 10⁻³), indicating stratified material layers.

Purpose:
To provide an observational reference for colleagues tracking 3I/ATLAS through perihelion. These outcomes are testable using existing or planned JWST MIRI/NIRSpec and VLT VISIR/CRIRES+ datasets.

Should any of these behaviours be confirmed or contradicted, please share updates here so that independent analyses can be refined accordingly.

— Christopher Portelli, Independent Researcher (UK)

1 Like